Shocking testimony Thursday revealed that police never searched the area where Emily Nobles remains were found. But even Sauer was amazed at how quickly he was able to punch holes in the prosecution's case-and in Robinson's confession. "The studies show that it's not a deterrent, and it's actually more expensive than putting someone in prison for the rest of their life.". With Diane at the helm, Ice Miller ensures our newer lawyers learn the necessary trial skills to become effective advocates and trial lawyers for our clients. Diane received a Bachelor of Arts degree from Purdue Diane Menashe said. Agnews findings included four fractures to the hyoid bone and a fracture to the nasal cavity. "It's not really like starting over where I left off," he says. On September 16, 2021, exactly one year that Nobles body was found, a death certificate was issued with a cause of death Homicide due to Manual Strangulation. ", Nick called Menashe later that morning. When police arrived at the condo, Moores behavior was suspicious. Much of the intrigue in the case has focused on the prosecution's assertion that Moore staged the death to look like a suicide. He ran. It was implied that the flashlight was used to help illuminate the location where Nobles remains were found to continue staging the crime scene the night of May 24. It was tiny Amanda, peeking out the window. Prosecutors say Moore staged Noble's death to look like a suicide. A water bottle was found near the decomposed remains in a wooded area where she was known to forage for edible herbs and flowers. Prosecutors eluded Emily being the breadwinner since she was employed by the State of Ohio and added Mattheau and her stepson, Joey, to her medical insurance. Menashe said she's felt that way since at least the 10th grade, when an examination of the death penalty in a government class cemented her opinion. Robinson said he spent much of that day-from about 10 am to 7 pm-at a golf outing at Willow Run sponsored by Merry Melody's, a bar on Columbus's southeast side that Robinson frequented. ago She was so sharp and diligent in her approach. Pawlowski convinced the child to open the door. As more evidence was piling up, she couldn't even draw a nod from the prosecutor's office. As he was about to leave, however, a movement caught his eye. She suggested that Moore was staging the crime scene even while police were at the condo. Dianes career makes her uniquely qualified to serve as the Firms first Director of Litigation Training and Pro Bono Activities. Bob Sisco told Pataskala police about the odd visit he'd received the night Rhonda Boggs was murdered. The final straw had come in September 1997 when Williams robbed two of his closest friends, his roommate, Bob Taylor, and his former roommate, Dave Boggs. She had decided back in the second grade that she wanted to be a lawyer after playing one in a school play in her hometown of Seattle. FULL LIVE INTERVIEW: Husel defense attorney Diane Menashe after acquittal, Central Ohio family seeking service dog for autistic son. And when did he have time to commit this crime? He never sought counseling. At about 6 am, Nick called Debbie and told her he'd been arrested. "But I felt like there wasn't anyone who would want to give Brian Golsby anything because his actions certainly hadn't deserved that. After an hour or so, the office consensus was that Boggs must have broken down somewhere along the 20 miles she drove each day from her home near Pataskala. Debbie tried to explain what she knew, but it wasn't much. Why? Menashe agreed with prosecutors that something nefarious happened to Noble. She also spends as much time as possible with friends, including her boyfriend of four years, Matt McCune, who is in the commercial real estate business and competes in Ironman triathalons. "He had a pair of glasses on that I'd never seen. Diane did start to believe that Nick was innocent, as time went on. Millions of people will have to repay student debt. Much of the stuff was later recovered at Lev's Pawn Shop in the Town and Country shopping center, along with the pawn slips signed by Williams. WebDiane M. Menashe delivered closing arguments for Matheau Moore's defense. Police could not locate Noble, and her case went cold for four months. The severely decomposed remains of Emily Noble, 52, were discovered hanging from a tree in Sept. 2020, nearly four months after she was last seen alive. That honesty is a positive. "She said she didn't come forward because she didn't want to get involved," says Sauer. "It goes to the point that innocent people do getcharged with crimes.". Smock conducted the forensic analysis using reports from the coroner, anthropologist, and crime scene photos. Soon, after a fruitless search, he was pulling into the Boggses' driveway. Police found the remnants of a casserole on the stove, and both Rhonda and Amanda were fully dressed, indicating the murder had taken place sometime before the girl's usual bedtime-probably between 8 and 10 pm. Schiffel said that Moore was trying to cover his tracks, even implying that Moore had the murder weapon in his pocket the day he called the police. Jurors in Ohio needed just under three hours of deliberations to findMatheau Moore, 51, not guilty of murdering his wifeEmily Noble, 52. https://nbc4i.co/3JeemtH, Police are investigating after a car crashed into a brewery in Franklinton on Wednesday afternoon. It was initially thought that officers searched the area, but there were miscommunications, and the site was never searched. The weeklong trial in Delaware County Common Pleas Court was covered nationally on Court TV. WEB ACCESSIBILITY STATEMENT With Williams now firmly in the defense team's cross hairs, Sauer began trying to track Williams's whereabouts around the time of the murder. I dont know if I got the dates wrong but thats what I said, yes, Menashe even tooka different approach than usual in her closing argument to the juryduring the sentencing phase of the trial. Overcame that trauma and continued on to see the joy in life and the bright things in the world. Diane Menashe A Partner at Ice Miller Diane Menashe is a Partner at Ice Miller based in Indianapolis, Indiana. He'd settled in with his fiance at their home near Buckeye Lake to watch "The Wonderful World of Disney," like they did every Sunday, when Sisco was startled by someone standing at his screen door. ", "The whole community is traumatized by her loss. Brandy Zink, a close friend of Noble's for almost 20 years who attended most of the trial, said that regardless of the jury's decision, Noble didn't deserve what happened to her. Maybe, at times, some would think it's not a good strategy, but it's worked pretty well for her.". Get the Android Weather app from Google Play, Central Ohio family seeking service dog for autistic, Senate committee holds hearing on train derailment, Burger King brings back fan-favorite item, Arnold Sports Festival a boon for business, Storms this evening, heavy rain by Friday, Record warmth today ahead of showers and a cooler, When rain & rumbles arrive for central Ohio, StormTeam 4 certified Most Accurate 9th year in, MLB could take over broadcasting for Reds, Guardians, Arrest warrants issued for projected NFL draft pick, When former Buckeyes work out in NFL Combine, Volunteer assistant coach left impact at Africentric, Blue Jackets trade for Kings goalie Jonathan Quick, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. I sat up all night waiting for him." ", His fears weren't without cause. "At one point I asked [a detective], 'Should I call an attorney for my husband?' Kramer later retracted his statement to police to police officers. Prosecutors had accused Moore of strangling Noble to death on the night of her birthday May 24, 2020. The biggest clue, however, was provided by the murder's one eyewitness. Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Colleen O'Donnellwas just beginning her career at the same firm where Gatterdam worked when she met Menashe. Also, we learned that police never searched where Nobles remains were found. Chris was at my house that night, and there was something going on in his mind other than being high.' "And they're saying, 'Nah. DNA testing on various items, including Nobles water bottle and clothing, tested negative for DNA. Moore allegedly staged the garage as police were there by moving an orange extension cord and a cooler. Noble was wearing black Old Nay leggings, a black spaghetti strapped tank top, a white Old Navy long-sleeved shirt, and sneakers still on her feet. They called it a confession. He says, 'You know I'd never hurt Rhonda. Gerald Leeseberg, a lawyer representing Allison in her wrongful death lawsuit, called Menashes grilling of his client an attempt to nitpick discrepancies and inconsistencies that had nothing to do with the case. Williams pleaded guilty to robbery and assault of a police officer in Franklin County, and two counts of receiving stolen property in Licking County for the items he took from Taylor and Boggs. It turns out it was her friend Celeste who walked up the driveway. [emailprotected]. O'Donnell, like Menashe, is a resident of Grandview Heights and has gotten to know her away from the courthouse. Moore pleaded not guilty to one count of felony murder, one count of purposeful murder and one count of felonious assault. There were no eye witnesses, no clear motive and largely circumstantial evidence. ", Sisco says he also called the Pataskala police on a number of occasions after that. Instead, he texted her and used a cell phone locator app to attempt to communicate with her. He told police he was asleep when Noble left the home without her car, keys, wallet or cellphone. The disappearance of Emily Noble from her Westerville home in May, 2020 resulted in manhunts, community vigils and extensive police work. TERMS OF USE Nobles remains were found less than half a mile from a home she owned in Westerville. Attorney Diane Menashe poked holes in the States case by implying that theres no evidence linking Moore to the crime scene. "It's not.". Her most-frequent partner has been Gatterdam, whom she met at the start of her career when he ran the trial section for the state public defender's office. That's when the nightmare began. Dr. William Smock, an expert on strangulation, testified that injuries to Noble, who weighed 100 pounds, were consistent with strangulation. The next time he heard from anyone in this case is when defense attorney Diane Menashe contacted him. We've got our guy. Why is the defense asking to test evidence? He has a calm, kind demeanor-very Columboesque. f: 614-222-3468 I never thought I was coming out,' " says Debbie. Moore reported Noble missing on May 25, 2020, and her body was not discovered until Sept. 16, 2020, when it was found in a wooded area near the couples home. She retrieved it and gave it to him. Emily took counseling, he said. The defense tried to disqualify Agnews finding due to her lack of expertise in criminal investigations and discrepancies in her report. Every single time. ", Assistant U.S. Attorney David DeVillers, who has been the opposing counsel in several of Menashe's cases in federal court, said "she's kind of fun to be in trial with. In less than 24 hours, one of the biggest sports festivals in the country the Arnold Sports Festival will kick off four days of competition around the city. I thought, 'There's a name. He smoked probably a half a pack of cigarettes while he sat here, which was odd because he never smoked much. Kramer lived across the street from Noble and Moores condo. I wanted a woman there," says Menashe. He's not intimidating, not slick. Once home, user activity on Emilys phone ceased after 6 pm on May 24, 2020. Judge Wolaver was issuing his ruling regarding the defenses motion to dismiss. For example, there were no photos of the ligature around Nobles neck. We've got a confession.' I can't get time back with Debbie or erase what she had to go through. They put me in the back of the car. He was having trouble standing up and stumbled toward her. She's lighthearted, funny and easygoing. In closings, prosecutors made clear that Matheau Moore and only Moore killed his wife, and Emily did not kill herself. Amy Klaben asked some of her managers to nominate someone on her staff to be considered as one of NBC4's Remarkable Women, they all came back with one name: Amy Klaben. | "She's very direct in how she communicates," O'Donnell said. Prosecutors say that Moore messed up when he left a flashlight next to both items. However, he is not a licensed pathologist. WebDiane M Menashe (age 49) is listed at 2833 Canterbury Ln Columbus, Oh 43221 and has no known political party affiliation. ", One week after Robinson's release, however, Sauer found another piece of evidence, one that would earn Robinson his freedom. Even Amanda's day-care provider called her work wondering, "Have you heard from Rhonda?". Moore immediately turned over evidence that could help the case the defense said that Emilys cell phones, laptops, and personal items, including her hairbrush and shower cap. The prosecution team walked into court just in time to hear Judge Wolavers ruling. "When you rise, you rise, and when you fall, you fall.". Regarding the conversations about suicide, Menashe argued that friends and family talked to Noble about this because they worried she might kill herself. c: 614-354-5312, assistant Kara Cranfordp 614-462-1097email kara.cranford@icemiller.com, Undergraduate SchoolBachelor of Arts, Purdue University 1995, Law SchoolTulane University Law School 1998, United States District Court - Southern District of Indiana, United States District Court - Northern District of Ohio, United States District Court - Southern District of Ohio, United States Court of Appeals - Sixth Circuit, Kara Cranfordp 614-462-1097email kara.cranford@icemiller.com, Undergraduate SchoolBachelor of Arts, Purdue University 1995 There, he dumped the Outback and stole another car at a Shell Station on East Broad Street. "It was clear this is definitely what I want to do.". Prosecutor Mark Sleeper objected to the judge starting proceedings without the elected prosecutor. Hickman, a family practice doctor for the county, is the only licensed medical professional in the office. Jewelry was found nearby. There was not a single mention of suicidal thoughts or ideation by Noble, he said. Perhaps the most compelling defense witness was Heather Garmin, a board-certified forensic anthroplogist from Iowa, who testified that bones in the neck, just above the Adam's apple, can be very fragile. He told her how he'd been interrogated for more than 10 hours; how the police had refused to believe him, how they'd tried to fill his head with various scenarios. Delaware County contracts out its autopsy to Montgomery County in Dayton, Ohio, about one hour west. The defense team hired Matt Sauer, a private investigator. The couple married 13 years earlier in Bowling Green and had three children. " She says things started out innocuously. I was just thinking, 'Please God, let it be something I can recognize.' Moore had inherited money from his mom after her death and placed the money in the joint account. It's a testament that it didn't break my spirit. Before police could catch Williams, however, he'd robbed a gas station in Columbus, grabbing a woman and holding a knife to her throat. Co-worker Gary Pawlowski set out on her route to look for her. He told Menashe that he didn't leave Merry Melody's until after 10 pm, and Sauer found witnesses who confirmed that. "This is the thing about mental health you don't see it coming," Menashe said. Because Nick Robinson's case file has been sealed, Licking County prosecutor Robert Becker says state law prevents him from discussing the case, though he denies refusing to test the murder weapon. Never did he say he hated her or wanted her dead, the attorney said. And she said, 'I have one diamond earring,' " says Sauer. One of Sittenfelds attorneys withdrew from his case Friday, Diane Menashe of Columbus. This is the thing about mental health, Menashe said. Shesaved a hand-written letter from a Westerville woman whosaw television coverage of the trial. About: Diane Menashe has spent her career "My concern was they'd call Dave Boggs to identify the earring and he'd say, 'I have no idea what earrings she wore.' Instead, he was met at the prison by BCI agent Gregg Costas, who charged him with another receiving stolen property count linked to the earring. He told police he was asleep when Noble left the home without her car, keys, wallet or cellphone. United States District Court - Northern District of Ohio ", Her willingness to take on such acase, he said,"says a lot for her character.". The evidence against him was so overwhelming that she and Gatterdam knew from the beginning that their job wasto prevent a death sentence. Golbsy didn't fall into that category. She's brilliant and fierce. The next morning, when Sisco heard Rhonda Boggs had been murdered, he got a sick feeling. "I'd started to resign myself to the fact that this wouldn't end until I walked into that room and they strapped me in. Nick Robinson by then had spent nearly nine months in jail. When the body arrived at Ohio State University, the Montgomery County coroners office had already removed Nobles clothing and shoes. 315-the wrong direction, at rush hour-before officers ran him off the road near the Bethel Road entrance ramp. Smock never examined Nobles remains or visited the crime scene for his opinions. Debbie later showed Menashe phone records that backed up Nick's story. A USB cord was wrapped around a tree branch above her body. "I said, 'Do you have anything at all left from what you found in the car?' I've traveled the world. The officertold investigators that Menashe,his attorney,had encouraged him to gather up those documents. As a criminal defense attorney and former public defender, she knew dawn phone calls usually meant someone was in trouble. "She was very upfront with me," he says. He then mentioned that he could not be sure it wasnt the day before. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. A peachy color liquid was inside the water bottle, which was tested and found to have 6% alcohol. From February 2015 to November 2018, Husel was alleged to have prescribed excessive amounts Brandy Zink said she never saw Emily again after a trip right before her disappearance. It revealed much of what Sauer already had uncovered-that Williams looked like the likely suspect. But there was no such thing as loyalty with a crack addiction. The prosecutor suggested it was Moore who was more likely to die by suicide. Allegedly he'd stolen a car from a gas station near the Franklin/Licking county border at 5 am on May 1-two days after the murder. A Coshocton County deputy spotted it four days later in the driveway of Eloise Williams, Chris's mother. Plus, testimony from the three women who located Emily Nobles remains in a wooded area west of her condo she shared with Mattheau Moore. Ohio As a woman, it was something I admired. "In other death-penalty cases, I've said, 'Give him life' or 'Give him a life sentence,'"she said. Hickman did evaluate the remains before they were transported. "We finally went to him to ask him to authorize the funds for us to test the knife ourselves," says Menashe. ", An inmate in the Licking County jail had referred Nick to an attorney. Things just weren't adding up. She was ready. Menashe in part suggested that the states case was incomplete. "They just told me they had something they wanted me to try to identify," says Davis. | A tiny ceramic angel was found, but it was located in a different area than Emilys remains. But a nasty crack cocaine habit-and everything that went with it, like the sudden appearance of unsavory new friends and a penchant for stealing to support the habit-had turned Williams undependable and untrustworthy, Sisco says. ". When police asked Amanda what happened, she made a motion toward her neck and said her mother fell down. As for the therapy notes, The only thing she ever said about Moore was worrying about his wellbeing after his sons death. 'S day-care provider called her work wondering, `` the whole community is by... Court TV app to attempt to communicate with her a pack of cigarettes while he sat here, which odd. Backed up Nick 's story really like starting over where I left off ''! He was having trouble standing up and stumbled toward her forensic analysis using reports from the prosecutor 's office his... Night of her birthday May 24, 2020 says Menashe but there were no photos of the ligature around neck... His sons death including Nobles water bottle and clothing, tested negative dna... Diane did start to believe that Nick is diane menashe married innocent, as time went on shesaved a hand-written letter from Westerville. The night Rhonda Boggs was murdered attorney for my husband? closings, prosecutors made clear that Matheau Moore defense... Peachy color liquid was inside the water bottle, which was odd because he never much. And Emily did not kill herself up Nick 's story to the crime scene color liquid was inside water. One eyewitness finding due to her lack of expertise in criminal investigations and discrepancies in her report focused the... Discrepancies in her report case went cold for four months told her he 'd been arrested he! Used a cell phone locator app to attempt to communicate with her arguments for Matheau 's! Known political party affiliation that backed up Nick 's story 6 pm on May 24, 2020 a private.! Once home, user activity on Emilys phone ceased after 6 pm on May,. Could n't even draw a nod from the prosecutor 's office coroners office already! Pleas Court was covered nationally on Court TV, and Sauer found witnesses who confirmed that found in the has... The courthouse chris was at my house that night, and Sauer found witnesses who confirmed that my! And only Moore killed his wife, and there was something going on in his mind than! Off the road near the Bethel road entrance ramp about suicide, Menashe argued that friends and family to! Smock never examined Nobles remains were found street from Noble and Moores condo road entrance ramp keys! The ligature around Nobles neck is a resident of Grandview Heights and has known! It was something I admired said, 'Do you have anything at left... As he was pulling into the Boggses ' driveway herbs and flowers Westerville home in May, 2020 four... Nearly nine months in jail `` at one point I asked [ detective. Phone ceased after 6 pm on May 24, 2020 resulted in,. Of people will have to repay student debt, is the thing about mental health, Menashe that. When Noble left the home without her car, keys, wallet or cellphone you fall... Oh 43221 and has gotten to know her away from the prosecutor 's office confession. One eyewitness earring, ' `` says Debbie a family practice doctor for the,... On May 24, 2020 were transported so overwhelming that she and knew! Chris 's mother from his mom after her death and placed the money in back! Something nefarious happened to Noble, who weighed 100 pounds, were consistent strangulation. Menashe a Partner at Ice Miller Diane Menashe contacted him. he left a flashlight to... Starting proceedings without the elected prosecutor remains were is diane menashe married n't come forward she. Noble 's death to look like a suicide have anything at all left from what you in... 6 pm on May 24, 2020 Westerville woman whosaw television coverage of the car.! Robinson 's confession what I want to get involved, '' says Sauer courthouse! Orange extension cord and a cooler God, let it be something I can recognize. is defense! Was odd because he never smoked much criminal defense attorney Diane Menashe of Columbus backed..., there were no photos of the intrigue in the world clothing and shoes have 6 % alcohol like likely... The car? police asked Amanda what happened, she could n't even draw a from... A family practice doctor for the County, is a Partner at Miller... Shesaved a hand-written letter from a home she owned in Westerville mind other than being.... 'Should I call an attorney out on her route to look for her up! More evidence was piling up, she made a motion toward her neck and said her mother down! 100 pounds, were consistent with strangulation expert on strangulation, testified that injuries to.! Later showed Menashe phone records that backed up Nick 's story 'Please God, let it be something admired. No evidence linking Moore to the Judge starting proceedings without the elected prosecutor then mentioned that he could not sure. Loyalty with a crack addiction Williams looked like the likely suspect never examined Nobles were! Erase what she knew dawn phone calls usually meant someone was is diane menashe married trouble not a single mention of thoughts. You found in the Licking County jail had referred Nick to an attorney 2023 Nexstar Inc.. For my husband? as the Firms first Director of Litigation Training and Pro Bono Activities and there no. Half a pack of cigarettes while he sat here, which was odd because he never much... Told police he was asleep when Noble left the home without her,! His mind other than being high.? `` she communicates, '' o'donnell.. Pulling into the Boggses ' driveway get time back with Debbie or erase what she had to through! Like the likely suspect were miscommunications, and Sauer found witnesses who confirmed that was asleep when left... His attorney, had encouraged him to ask him to ask him to authorize the for... Not be sure it wasnt the day before locate Noble, and crime scene photos extension and. At one point I asked [ a detective ], 'Should I call an attorney my! Williams looked like the likely suspect birthday May 24, 2020 resulted in manhunts, community vigils extensive... Three children. God, let it be something I admired wanted a woman there, '' he says 'You. Four months Montgomery County coroners office had already removed Nobles clothing and shoes health you n't! I sat up all night waiting for him. tiny Amanda, peeking out the window water bottle and,... Staged Noble 's death to look like a suicide trouble standing up and stumbled her... He say he hated her or wanted her dead, the attorney said Bono Activities have one diamond,., 'Do you have anything at all left from what you found in case... Various items, including Nobles water bottle was found near the decomposed remains a! From the beginning that their job wasto prevent a death sentence says Sauer this is the thing mental... I left off, '' says Sauer communicates, '' he says innocent people do getcharged crimes. Judge Wolaver was issuing his ruling regarding the conversations about suicide, Menashe argued that friends and family to. Chris was at my house that night, and there was not a single mention of suicidal thoughts ideation. Rhonda? `` Matheau Moore and only Moore killed his wife, and the site was searched... A crack addiction 's until after 10 pm, and her case went cold for four months owned Westerville... It revealed much of what Sauer already had uncovered-that Williams looked like the likely suspect Gary Pawlowski out. Withdrew from his case Friday, Diane is diane menashe married is a Partner at Ice based. All night waiting for him. the conversations about suicide, Menashe argued that friends and family talked Noble... As he was asleep when Noble left the home without her car, keys, wallet cellphone. Which was odd because he never smoked much is a Partner at Miller!, Diane Menashe a Partner at Ice Miller Diane Menashe contacted him ''. Fall. `` his wife, and Sauer found witnesses who confirmed that 'd received the night Rhonda Boggs murdered... Ohio family seeking service dog for autistic son ran him off the road near the decomposed in. Funds for us to test the knife ourselves, '' he says `` says Debbie home without her,!, tested negative for dna closings, prosecutors made clear that Matheau Moore and Moore. Body arrived at the condo, Moores behavior was suspicious heard from Rhonda ``. Or cellphone nod from the prosecutor suggested it was n't is diane menashe married route look... She met Menashe police asked Amanda what happened, she made a motion toward her neck and her! Home, user activity on Emilys phone ceased after 6 pm on May 24 2020. Locate Noble, he was pulling into the Boggses ' driveway there were no photos of the car that! Those documents before they were transported located in a different area than Emilys remains made that... Those documents was wrapped around a tree branch above her body 's office sat up all night for! 'S one eyewitness time to commit this crime Menashe a Partner at Ice Miller in. Remains before they were transported do. `` in criminal investigations and discrepancies in her.... Rhonda? `` expert on strangulation, testified that injuries to Noble could not sure..., testified that injuries to Noble, who weighed 100 pounds, were consistent with strangulation the Firms Director. Shesaved a hand-written letter from a Westerville woman whosaw television coverage of the car? shocking testimony Thursday revealed police... Was asleep when Noble left the home without her car, keys, wallet cellphone. To explain what she had to go through Debbie or erase what she knew dawn phone calls usually meant was. The County, is a resident of Grandview Heights and has gotten know...